EVALUASI PROGRAM TARBIYAH ANAK SALEH (TRANS) DI SEKOLAH DASAR ISLAM TERPADU (SDIT) AL-BASHIRAH MENGGUNAKAN DISCREPANCY EVALUATION MODEL

Abstract

The Tarbiyah Anak Saleh (TRANS) Program is a character and religious development program for students at Al-Bashirah Integrated Islamic Elementary School (SDIT Al-Bashirah). Although the program has been implemented as one of the school’s flagship programs, it has never been systematically evaluated to identify discrepancies between its planning and implementation. This study aims to identify and measure the discrepancies between the planning and implementation of the TRANS Program using the Discrepancy Evaluation Model (DEM), which comprises four evaluation stages: design, installation, process, and product. The study employed an evaluation approach using a mixed-method design and was conducted from February 23 to March 7, 2026. Data were collected through questionnaires, interviews, and documentation. The questionnaires were administered to 132 students in Grades IV, V, and VI, while interviews were conducted with 3 teachers involved in implementing the program. The findings show that the overall discrepancy level of the TRANS Program was categorized as small. At the design stage, the program was supported by competent human resources and adequate facilities and infrastructure, although several activities had not yet been implemented and detailed technical guidelines were not available. At the installation stage, the level of program conformity reached 80%, with a discrepancy of 20%, categorized as small, although internet connectivity and transportation constraints were still encountered. At the process stage, the level of conformity also reached 80%, with a discrepancy of 20%, categorized as small, supported by the involvement of the school, teachers, parents, and students. At the product stage, the level of program achievement reached 84%, with a discrepancy of 16%, categorized as very small, as reflected in positive changes in students’ worship practices, moral character, discipline, and responsibility. These findings indicate that the TRANS Program demonstrates a high level of conformity and achievement; however, stronger technical guidelines and greater consistency in implementation are still needed to ensure that all program components are carried out optimally.

ABSTRAK

Program Tarbiyah Anak Saleh (TRANS) merupakan program pembinaan karakter dan keagamaan peserta didik di Sekolah Dasar Islam Terpadu (SDIT) Al-Bashirah. Meskipun program ini telah dilaksanakan sebagai salah satu program unggulan sekolah, belum pernah dilakukan evaluasi secara sistematis untuk mengetahui kesenjangan antara perencanaan dan pelaksanaannya. Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mengidentifikasi dan mengukur kesenjangan antara perencanaan dan pelaksanaan Program TRANS menggunakan Discrepancy Evaluation Model (DEM), yang mencakup empat tahap evaluasi, yaitu desain, instalasi, proses, dan produk. Penelitian menggunakan pendekatan evaluasi dengan metode campuran (mixed method) yang dilaksanakan pada 23 Februari–7 Maret 2026. Data dikumpulkan melalui angket, wawancara, dan dokumentasi. Angket diberikan kepada 132 peserta didik kelas IV, V, dan VI, sedangkan wawancara dilakukan terhadap 3 guru yang terlibat dalam pelaksanaan program. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa tingkat kesenjangan Program TRANS secara umum berada pada kategori kecil. Pada tahap desain, program telah didukung oleh sumber daya manusia yang kompeten dan sarana prasarana yang memadai, meskipun beberapa kegiatan belum terlaksana dan belum tersedia petunjuk teknis yang rinci. Pada tahap instalasi, tingkat kesesuaian program mencapai 80% dengan kesenjangan 20% dalam kategori kecil, meskipun masih terdapat kendala jaringan dan transportasi. Pada tahap proses, tingkat kesesuaian mencapai 80% dengan kesenjangan 20% dalam kategori kecil, didukung oleh keterlibatan sekolah, guru, orang tua, dan peserta didik. Pada tahap produk, tingkat ketercapaian mencapai 84% dengan kesenjangan 16% dalam kategori sangat kecil, yang ditunjukkan oleh perubahan positif pada aspek ibadah, akhlak, kedisiplinan, dan tanggung jawab peserta didik. Temuan ini menunjukkan bahwa Program TRANS memiliki tingkat kesesuaian dan ketercapaian yang tinggi, tetapi masih memerlukan penguatan petunjuk teknis dan konsistensi pelaksanaan agar seluruh komponen program dapat terlaksana secara optimal.